nj lottery winnings taxable

Get ready to say no a lot, accountant tells Mega Millions mystery winner

The most valuable lottery ticket in New Jersey state history was sold at the Riverdale Lukoil South station. Despite the fact the drawing was last week we still do not know who owns the millions. This video details what we do know. 4/2/18

An attendant speaks to reporters after the New Jersey Lottery announced that Friday’s winning Mega Millions ticket, now worth $533 million, was sold at the Lukoil station on Route 23 south in Riverdale. (Photo: Jai Agnish/

Story Highlights

  • Lottery jackpots are really taxed at 46% in NJ, not 25%.
  • Hire a professional accountant, attorney, and broker.
  • Don’t change your lifestyle too much.
  • Get ready for people to come a-knocking.

RIVERDALE — Be ready to say no — a lot!

That’s advice from an accountant to the winner of the $533 million New Jersey Mega Millions, whoever that may be.

Daniel Mahler, certified public accountant with Gisler & Mahler in Bloomingdale recommends the winner practice saying no to requests he will most likely get and seek professional financial help as well.

The winning $533 million NJ Mega Millions ticket was sold in Riverdale on March 30 and no winner has stepped forward.

Mahler, who is also mayor of Wanaque, said his law firm represented a $38 million lottery winner in the 1980s.

Station manager Nash Riad, who was contacted by lottery officials Saturday morning, said he is unsure who bought the winning ticket, now worth $533 million. (Photo: Viorel Florescu/

The $38 million winner is doing just fine, he said. He moved to Florida. His accountant followed him there and started a new firm.

Not all who win major jackpots fare as well. Mahler said some go broke.

So, here are some tips for the new winner.

Expect to pay a boatload in taxes

Lots of the winnings will go toward income tax. Forget the 25 percent number that’s been floating around out there. Mahler says it’s more like 46 percent when all is said and done.

If the winner opts for the cash value option of $324 million, $149 million goes to taxes, leaving $175 million. The winner also has the option of receiving the $533 million over 30 years and to pay tax on the yearly amount.

Just got off the phone with the wonderful folks at @TheNJLottery. Still no sign of the winner. Winner has 359 days to claim the prize. We’ll let you know when we know. via @northjersey

Where did 46 percent come from? Welcome to the millionaire tax bracket. It’s 37 percent now under President Donald Trump — down from 39.6 percent.

In fact, Trump actually saved our local yet-to-be-identified Mega Millions winner $8.4 million, Mahler — a Republican — is quick to point out.

The rest of the 46 percent is made up of 9 percent from New Jersey’s income tax rate. Mahler pointed out that New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy, a Democrat, is trying to get a new millionaires tax rate passed from 9 percent to 11 percent.

“If he does that it will most likely be retroactive and he’ll get whacked,” Mahler said of New Jersey’s new lottery winner.

It would wipe out a lot of the aforementioned Trump benefit, he said.

The bottom line: In New Jersey lottery winners can expect to give about half of their winnings to pay taxes.

Tax season: Mahler said winners also had better file their taxes on time every year because when you’re talking millions of dollars, the penalty on a late payment will sting.

Side note: Did you know in California lottery winners don’t have to pay state taxes on the jackpot money? Just saying.

Get some pros to help you out

Mahler said lottery winners should take their time coming forward, and they need to line up the professionals.

“Get a good attorney, good accountant, good broker,” he said.

“This guy has to watch himself. Everybody’s going to come after him. Everybody looks for a handout.”

Wanaque Mayor Daniel Mahler, also an accountant, on New Jersey’s Mega Millions winner

He said some people simply can’t handle that type of money.

“These numbers are staggering,” Mahler said.

Mahler said he is personally a big fan of municipal bonds for a steady 3 to 4 percent income stream.

“You have to protect your wealth,” he said.

A 3 or 4 percent return on millions of dollars is a lot of money, he said.

Don’t change your lifestyle

Mahler said the winner probably won’t be shopping at the Riverdale Walmart down the highway ever again, but winners should live the way they lived before the money.

He even suggested lottery winners live at the same means and put the rest of the money away.

“Enjoy life,” he said. “You have to do something with your life.”

But, he said, winners should keep their job or volunteer somewhere.

Get ready to say, ‘no!’

Mahler said lottery winners need to be prepared for when people start asking them for money.

“This guy has to watch himself,” he said of New Jersey’s big winner. “Everybody’s going to come after him. Everybody looks for a handout.”

He recalled when someone knocked on a lottery winner’s front door with a sob story about how a family member had cancer and asked for money.

“People just knocked on his door,” Mahler said. “He had to change his phone number because people kept calling him. Everybody’s going to be after you.”

Ameer Krass, owner of Riverdale Lukoil South, speaks about the winning lottery ticket on Monday, April 2, 2018. The most valuable lottery ticket in New Jersey history was sold at his store. The annuity jackpot for the drawing, which took place Friday, is $533 million. (Photo: Kevin R. Wexler/

Mahler said he has a lot of respect for the owner of the lucky Lukoil in Riverdale, Ameer Krass. The Route 23 south location sold the winning Mega Millions ticket to last week’s mystery winner. Krass claims he knows who the winner is because he says he reviewed surveillance footage and determined that the winner is a frequent customer.

But, Krass said he has not tried to contact the lucky ticket holder, and he urged anyone who might know them to give the winner “the space they deserve.”

Email: [email protected] Follow Jai Agnish on Twitter and Instagram: @jaiagnish

Don’t miss a thing

Download our apps and get alerts for local news, weather, traffic and more. iPhone app | iPad app | Android app | Find us on social media: Twitter | Sports Twitter | Facebook | Instagram | Food Instagram

A local accountant, whose firm represented a $38 million lottery winner offers some advice to NJ's $533 million Mega Millions winner. Say no – a lot!

NJ Lottery winner has no luck with tax dispute

The state Division of Taxation in Trenton has prevailed in a dispute with a New Jersey Lottery winner. (Photo: Jim Walsh, Staff photographer)

TRENTON – A big winner in the New Jersey Lottery ran out of luck when it came to his taxes.

A state judge on Monday ruled against Mitchell Medoff, a Princeton man who mistakenly paid taxes of almost $94,000 on a Lottery prize of $7.5 million.

Medoff had demanded a refund of his overpayments for tax years 2009 through 2012, arguing he “detrimentally relied” on the state Division of Taxation’s interpretation of a law taxing Lottery winnings of more than $10,000.

The agency said the tax applied to Lottery winnings that preceded the 2009 law, like Medoff’s. A Tax Court decision in another case rejected that view in 2016, and Medoff requested a return of his payments about six months later.

But the new interpretation came too late for Medoff, a 1993 Lottery winner.

New Jersey has a three-year deadline to file claims for a refund of overpayments, Tax Court Judge Mark Cimino noted in Monday’s ruling.

And for Medoff’s last possible claim on his 2012 overpayment, the clock stopped ticking in April 2015.

Medoff argued the time limit should be waived to avoid “a manifest injustice,” arguing “he had no way to know that he was not required to pay his tax until the court’s 2016 rulings,” Cimino’s ruling said.

But the judge agreed with the tax agency’s stance that Medoff had filed late and “no exception applies.”

An attorney for Medoff, David Neufeld of Cherry Hill, could not be reached for immediate comment.

Medoff received annuity payments from the Lottery of about $371,000 per year through 2012.

Because the 2009 law called for the tax on Lottery winnings “to take effect immediately,” Medoff paid taxes on his annuity ranging from around $22,000 in 2009 to $24,000 in 2012.

But three Lottery winners challenged the law in Tax Court in 2011. The eventual ruling in their case barred the state from taxing prizes won before 2009 “because taxpayers who participated in and won those lotteries understood that their winnings would be tax-free,” Cimino observed.

NJ Lottery (Photo: File)

However, he noted, the three challengers still paid taxes on their Lottery winnings to avoid penalties and interest while waging their court fight. But they also filed amended returns seeking refunds “almost immediately.”

Cimino said Medoff “had the opportunity” to join that fight or mount a similar challenge “at any point after he submitted his 2009 and later years’ tax returns.”

“There is no claim in this case that the Director (of the Division of Taxation) ever prevented the taxpayer from filing an amended return and seeking a refund,” the judge said.

He also noted the state Supreme Court has ruled that “strict adherence to statutory time limitations is essential in tax matters, borne of the exigencies of taxation and the administration of government.”

Jim Walsh: @jimwalsh_cp; 856-486-2646; [email protected]

Also in South Jersey

  • Subaru recalling 1.3 million cars over brake lights
  • Doctor who didn’t touch Bible gets new trial over harassment claim
  • Cherry Hill dentist’s Bali trip ends in tragedy
  • Boardwalk views can be surprising along the Jersey Shore

Don’t miss a thing

Download our apps and get alerts for local news, crime, weather, traffic and more. Search “Courier-Post” in the app store or use these links from your device: iPhone app | Android app | iPad app. And be sure to ‘like’ us on Facebook!

Judge denies refund to man who mistakenly paid more than $90,000 in tax on New Jersey Lottery prize